Women Before an Aquarium - Henri Matisse (1921-22)

Baby Fish

Vee Venning


I used to live in this wide, rounded building covered in pink tiles that shone like early morning light. Whenever I went inside, I would leave my rubber clogs right outside the door, toes pointed towards the rest of the world. They were a dull silver, the kind that only shines when it’s wet. It always reminded me of those slippery rocks you pick out of the river. In the moment they look like gems, but by the time you get home, they’ve dried, and that gleam has evaporated. 

I really loved that place, the quality of the light that came through the windows, and the way the squarish windows split up the tile and made the building look like a big, misshapen pomegranate packed with glowing seeds. Now the building remains, but it’s all wrong. They ripped off those pink tiles and redid the whole thing. Now it’s oppressive plaster, white and looming like some great big whale opening its mouth to swallow you whole. 

I lived there until I couldn’t anymore. I loved it, but after a certain point it felt like someone had stuck their hands inside me and mixed everything up. Things stopped making sense. The world felt like it had been washed out like an old yogurt container getting ready to be recycled. There were traces of things I recognized, but nothing of significance. And it was myself that I missed 

most of all. I became this new thing, not really a person but some kind of form: arms and legs and a head and not much more. It felt all wrong to be inside that apartment, which I had so many dear memories in. 

After it happened, the bed always felt too lumpy or too soft. My feet would hang off the end of it, and I wondered if I had grown from this new body swallowing the old one. Every day, I would leave before the sun could rise, and in the dark moments of the morning that are indistinguishable from night, I felt safe. I thought, “No one can hurt me here.” I’d leave the apartment and walk around while the sun rose. I always felt the most hopeful in the mornings, with the sun’s promise burning holes into my vision. It was like she was telling me to go back to sleep, trying to recreate the night by cutting out bits of dawn. 

I would keep myself as busy as possible during daylight hours, then I’d stay out as late as I could, until it really was night again. All sorts of words would come to me on those walks. They’d float through my mind like leaves falling from trees, and I cherished them so. But at some point, no matter what I did, no matter where I went, the day would always have to end. And I would never get to decide when that was. I could try to stay up all night and catch the sun rising, but there was always going to be a time when I closed my eyes, no matter how long I put it off. 

That was one of the things I hated most. How the days would always come to an end. How I would have to close my eyes and go to some unknowable place. But where did I go? And what did I do there? Sleeping was so lonely it made me want to die. It’s in that moment, really, the one right between closing your eyes and falling asleep, that you feel the most alone. It’s when you realize that you can’t bring anyone into your dreams. When you realize that your skull is impenetrable, and that no matter how tightly we are held, there’s always going to be some miniature version of ourselves floating around in there all alone, screaming for company. 

Every time I lay down in that apartment, it was all I could think of — how lonely I was, and how even if I had someone around, I’d be lonelier still. Anyways, I couldn’t take it anymore, so I moved out to some boring flat across the city. Shortly thereafter, they renovated the old building. This new one had no memories and I sank into it like I would an empty riverbed. Its pebbles were already dry, so I didn’t have to worry about what they looked like shiny. I got rid of almost everything I owned during the move. I just felt so guilty, looking back on all these posters and thinking about who owned them before and how I was a sad excuse for that person. It felt wrong to surround myself with their things. To wear their face seemed punishment enough. 

If I thought really hard, I could remember what they were like. I could sort through their belongings and wear their clothes. People bought it too, at first. I didn’t want to disappoint them, so I reached inside myself searching for something to return to them. Like throwing a bucket down into a well, I dredged up old words and tried them on for size. But I began to get nervous that people were catching on. I can’t say for sure if they were, but what I can say is that I didn’t like what I was doing. 

More than anything, I wished that whatever had happened could be undone. I wished for it in those early mornings and in those late nights and in all the time that dragged on in between. I wanted to be that person again, but I barely knew them. It felt like trying to draw someone from memory, but for a long time I tried. It made me so sad, sadder than anything, to try to fit this new form into those old clothes, to slip my big feet into those silver shoes. I was stretching everything out, ruining the image of something that I had little recollection of. 

Eventually I decided that I should just give up on it and try to preserve what was left of them. There wasn’t much writing, a lot of that came after. But there were drawings and decorations, pins and clips, and a big collection of other things. I could tell that they really liked to have stuff around, but looking at all those things only made me sad. I wondered what was so special about them, why this person had collected them and what they had meant. 

It wasn’t as if my memory fully disappeared. It was more like someone had placed a thick layer of glass over everything that had happened in my life, and I was standing on top of that, looking down into this abyss, totally helpless. Some memories were closer than others, and some were so far down that they were just shapes and colors, but they were all untouchable. And the longer I stood on that glass plane, the farther away they got. New memories came in like sand with the tide, scratching up the glass and making it harder and harder to see down there.

I tried not to let on how much it bothered me, but it was what I mourned most. Those far-away memories blinked like a lighthouse, and I sensed that that person had been wonderful and bright.

Here I was, destroying their legacy. It kept me up at night. 

I did various things to keep me busy in the wake of my change. I read plenty of books, and I wrote all the time. Writing was one of the few things I did out of instinct. The words were mine, but at the same time they weren’t. They just came to me, like sticking out your tongue and waiting for a snowflake to fall on it. I felt so confused during those days, it was like I couldn’t tell where I was or where I was supposed to go, but I felt life dragging me along nonetheless. I didn’t know how to stop it. I don’t think one is allowed to. So I just kept writing and writing. Grabbing those letters and stringing them into a garland and wrapping myself up in it. It became my whole world, my only semblance of solace. 

I had stopped working at this point, and if I lived carefully I wouldn’t have to for about a year. Before, I had worked a steady job and made a decent salary. I was never a big spender, so I had plenty of savings and my new apartment was almost half the price of my old one. Pretty much all I did was walk and read and write. I stopped seeing all the people that used to know me because I couldn’t bear breaking the news that I was different now. I thought that if I mourned alone, no one else would have to, so I kept to myself. I distributed all that old stuff that made me feel so depressed, and once it was gone I stopped answering my phone. 

I didn’t know what to say to them. When I tried to speak to the people who had loved that other person so dearly, it only made the memories seem farther away. It was like a big gust of wind blew through my mind and carried all my words to some far-away place. At first, I would try to read aloud from the memories below the glass. I stumbled over my words and sometimes skipped lines. Nothing I said made sense, but they looked on with expectant smiles as if I just needed time. I could tell that the glass wasn’t going anywhere, only I had no idea how to explain this. It was easier to fade out of their lives and hope that they forgot about me than it was to try and explain myself. I didn’t know what to tell them. 

One day, I decided to take the train to the edge of the city and walk around there. It was summer and the train led right up to the edge of the sparkling ocean. I decided to get lunch and write by the water. When I got off the train I saw signs for a new aquarium. They seemed to be left over from its grand opening which had been just under a month ago. I felt compelled to go and decided it would be a good place to write. Also, I wanted to see dolphins. 

I walked into the air-conditioned lobby and it smelled faintly of salt. It was a Tuesday afternoon, but it was still relatively busy. I saw kids running around stamping things in little booklets, moms pushing strollers and chiding their kids to stay close by. There were a few couples too, holding hands and pointing into dark squares of glass. I paid for my ticket and wandered into the area closest to the entrance. It contained big cylindrical tanks with the kind of fish you can only imagine in a fish tank. With their neon stripes and pointed fins it was hard to believe they had ever lived in the ocean. 

I kept walking and went into a darker room full of jellyfish of all different sizes. They were like gauzy parachutes, floating every which way and bouncing off of each other. I stayed in here for a while, watching them until I decided to move on. The next room was bigger than the rest. I could tell we were in the center of the building because there was a two-story tank, flanked by rows of rounded bench seating. I sat down towards the back, watching the backs of the heads of the people sitting in front of me. The tank was full of fish, big and small, eels, even sharks. 

As I stared at the fish and all the heads of the people looking at them, I considered killing myself. I just couldn’t stop thinking about how I needed to preserve the good image of that person that we all loved so much. I was destroying it, taking my two hands and pinching pieces of it off until it was almost gone. I didn’t want to do that. More than anything, I wanted to be that person again. But I knew it was impossible. I didn’t know how to live with what had happened to me, but I knew that I would have to carry it forever. Giving up seemed like the only option. And yet I knew that it was forbidden. It all seemed so unfair. I looked at those fish and wished I was one of them, bobbing around in that big glass tank, with no words and no way to say them. 

I stayed there for another hour or two, mostly because I couldn’t get up. My body got so heavy I could barely lift my head. I knew the trek home was long and far, and that made me want to start it even less. I wondered how long I could stay there before people started to notice. But I knew that eventually, and sooner rather than later, the aquarium would have to close up, lock the doors and banish all the fish to night. 

I was sitting on the train, staring at the advertisements when I realized I was one stop away from home. I got out and started walking. Typically, the walk from the station took about ten minutes. It was a gentle downward slope lined with bright trees. But today I could barely get up the stairs. I waited for the elevator and pressed the button once I stepped inside. As soon as I got outside I thought about calling a taxi. I really didn’t know if I could make the walk, but there were no taxis and so I stumbled toward my place. It felt like the only thing to do was trudge through time and wait for this horrible thing to expire. The rest of the day passed, and I let it. 

***

I couldn’t tell you what happened after that, but one day I woke up and had no idea where I was. I looked around to find that I was in some dull apartment. There was a mattress in the middle of the floor with grayish sheets falling off the corner of it. To the right of the mattress were a few stacks of paperbacks lined against the wall, some empty glasses, and not much else. I was shocked by how little the room contained. It looked like some forgotten wing of a hospital, and suddenly I felt sad instead of scared. I couldn’t place the feeling. All I could sense was this deep hole somewhere in my heart, but I couldn’t tell why it was there or how long it had been there. All I felt was this dull ache, like an apple that had been eaten by a worm. Other than that, I seemed fine. 

I saw my phone half-tucked under the sheet and grabbed it. I had no missed messages, only an email from my pharmacy announcing some holiday sale. Nothing else seemed awry, except for the fact that I most certainly wasn’t at home. I left the apartment in search of it and realized 

that I was almost all the way across the city. I used my phone to navigate to the station, and a train arrived as soon as I reached the bottom of the stairs. I had to transfer once, but I was back in my neighborhood relatively quickly. 

I reached the place where my building was supposed to be, but instead of that shining place there was this big white thing. It looked so unpleasant with its small square windows floating around in foam. They looked like they had gotten swept away in a storm. 

I got back on the train and headed across the city. Things were coming back to me in bits and pieces, and it was clear now that the pallid apartment was my own. I knew what stop to get off at, and how to walk from the station without checking my phone. I figured that a little under a year had passed since I had moved there. Fear struck me hot and stark, and I felt something move in my chest. Some entirely new sensation was in there, sleeping and flicking its tail. I dropped to my knees and grabbed at my shirt. The pain was excruciating and deep. I wasn’t sure how something like this could have been living inside me without me noticing immediately. I waited for it to pass and wondered if it might kill me. Tears streamed down my face and I pulled my knees to my chest. 

After a while, I looked around and found myself back in that bleak room. I turned the lights on and drank from an old glass of water. I felt it run down into my stomach and drag dust with it. 

Something bad had happened, that much was clear. But whatever it was was lost to me. I shuddered to think that any single event could change my heart so thoroughly. It was in my veins and wrapped around every piece of hair. It felt like I had new skin.

That night I couldn’t sleep. I wanted to know so badly what had damaged me in such a way, but I was terrified to find out and wondered how long I could go without remembering. It wasn’t that I felt relief, but more so that I felt as though the next shoe would drop at any minute. What would 

happen when I found out? Would it be as bad as the first time I’d already forgotten? I didn’t know. 

I threw away my phone in fear that someone might text me and remind me of what had happened. I stopped checking my mail, I stopped going on walks. I was so worried that I might run into someone I knew, and that they would bring it back to life. All I felt was this unfounded sense of despair. I had no idea what had been done to me and I was too afraid to find out. It was hard to compare this to the sadness I had felt before, but I figured this was worse. Why was it that every time something happened to me, it seemed to hurt more than anything before it? Would things only get worse from here? Was every challenge going to get harder and harder until finally I couldn’t take it anymore? That’s how things were looking. 

I began making plans to kill myself. I couldn’t take it anymore, but really I couldn’t take it again. I was just so afraid of finally remembering whatever it was that had torn my soul apart so roughly. I don’t know how I had existed in a world where I had to remember whatever it had been, and now that I lived in one where I didn’t, the thought of returning made me eager to die. 

What made me the most sad was thinking of the life that I had lived before all this. I’m sure I had been sad at times, even terribly so, but in the face of this thing, all I felt towards that former anguish was envy. Sad things had happened and people hurt me, and maybe I hurt them too. But still, there was this small piece of myself that remained unfazed by it all. Like a rock in a stream, all that hurt flowed over it and it stayed right where it was. 

That piece was gone now, or at the very least damaged in some irreparable way. Some storm had blown through and mixed it up with a legion of other rocks that looked pretty much the same. Or maybe the storm had totally wrecked it, turned it into sand and scattered it inside my body. At times I wondered if I was being dramatic, and in truth, I hoped I was. But I knew that I wasn’t. I knew now that life could get a lot worse than I had ever realized. 

They were the most hellish of days and by the end of each one I had sworn to kill myself. But then the next day began, and then it ended, and the days just went by without you really being able to touch them. I just couldn’t bring myself to end things. 

Every night I would dream of it, that thing that had happened to me. But as soon as I woke up I would forget it. I couldn’t seem to die, but I couldn’t seem to do much of anything else either.

Finally, I took myself back to the aquarium in hopes that I might get hit by a car on the way there or drown in the dolphin tank. I wasn’t sure what exactly would happen when I went there, only that it had been the last place I could remember going before forgetting. Though full of despair, those days had been marked by purpose, some belief that there was something greater than myself and that if I wrote enough words and walked enough steps I might come to understand it. 

So I went back to that sparkling place, and there it sat, just as I had left it. So close to the edge of the ocean that it might fall in if I breathed on it. It seemed to rest right on the horizon. Those fish owned the world, I thought. 

I walked in and breathed that salty smell. I was sure that all the people must be different from the ones that were inside the last time I was here, and yet I could find no proof of such. The children scampering around might really be the same as last time, and what was to stop it from being so? I felt so disconnected from the spinning world; I looked at babies in strollers and wanted to cry for them. I wanted to shake their mothers and berate them for daring to bring life into the world. “Look at me,” I thought. Your children might become like this, bodies sinking deep into the world, all sensation, no memory, some inanimate thing experiencing things and forgetting them as soon as they were over. I wondered why they even bothered dragging those strollers here, it’s not as if the babies would remember any of this. Every time here was their first time, and their glee was endless. 

It seemed unfair that the babies should remember nothing and be so happy, all the while I remembered nothing and felt only misery. I was getting so angry thinking about these stupid babies and their toothless grins. I barely looked at the fish. 

I realized then that I wanted someone to take care of me. I couldn’t take care of myself and hadn’t been. But it seemed so wrong to ask anyone else to do it. I understood in some distant way that I was allowed and even encouraged to, yet simultaneously I felt as though it was one of those things that was supposed to be offered but never accepted. Did people truly want to be there for me? Or did they only want to give the impression that they could be? What did it even mean to “be there” for someone, when weren’t we already there? Wasn’t that the main condition of existence, that we were there whether we wanted to be or not? 

It seemed cruel that this was something you had to ask for, something that you had to explain. I had realized relatively early on that people want to believe that things are better than they are and they will assume it is so until proven otherwise. People are eager to believe that one is healed or even unaffected by tragedy. So how does one explain that their life has been destroyed, their personhood stolen? That there is something greater than ourselves and it is not benevolent but random, meddling in our lives with its celestial eyes shut? I wanted someone to take care of me, but at the same time I couldn’t allow it. I couldn’t reveal that disgusting part of myself, so affected by the world. It was night now, and I stared at the moon which shone so brightly that it resembled the sun. I wondered what would become of me. 

I went to the aquarium every day after that. The tickets were relatively expensive, and I knew that I would run out of money sooner rather than later if I kept it up. But it seemed to be the only thing I could do, the only place I could go. When I sat, surrounded by infantile innocence and fish stranded in glass, I felt angry instead of sad. And that made me happy. The rage was tangible, and I let it roll around in my mouth like a piece of melting ice. I swore at babies under my breath. I laughed with the fish and felt as though I somehow shared their plight. I touched the glass even though I wasn’t supposed to. No one ever reprimanded me. My fingerprint just became one of many smaller ones. There was my trace. It felt good to leave one of those. 

After a few weeks of this, I became quite sick. It started with exhaustion, but by that point I had gotten so used to being tired that I didn’t notice anything out of the ordinary. But after a few days of that sickness I certainly noticed something was awry. My limbs felt as if they had turned into heavy lumber, and my head ached so badly that I could barely stand. I blamed it on those toddlers at the aquarium, always coughing with small o-shaped mouths and nothing to cover them. 

The sickness wouldn’t go away, and finally I decided to drag myself to the doctor. I treated myself to a taxi. When I got there, the lights were so bright that I had trouble opening my eyes all the way. I was squinting and it felt like someone had knotted all my eyelashes together. They called my name and I stepped into the examination room. Immediately, I threw up all over the floor. At some point, I started crying. There was a doctor asking me questions and someone cleaning the floor. I couldn’t stop staring at the mop wiping that vomit up and absorbing it into its grayish strands. I wondered where it would go after this. 

Finally, I began to listen to the doctor who was getting increasingly flustered at my lack of response. She asked me what my symptoms were and I spoke for the first time in what felt like forever. It was hard to form words. I thought that maybe I could close my eyes and sleep on top of the paper that I was sitting on until I felt better. I liked how it crinkled everywhere I touched it. Another trace, I thought. 

Eventually, they sent me home with antibiotics and a thick packet detailing the “DO’S” and “DO NOTS” of being sick. I threw it out in the lobby and took a mint from the receptionist’s desk. I called a taxi home and fell asleep in the back. I woke to the driver shaking me. He told me that I was a very heavy sleeper. I paid him and walked up to my apartment.

That night I decided that I needed to change something or finally kill myself. Ever since forgetting, I considered the idea of being dead as some wonderful escape, somewhere I could stay until I got better. But death was no joke. I knew that if I was going to kill myself everything would be over. My soul would disappear from this world, and, as soon as they cleaned the tanks at the aquarium, every trace of me would be gone. I thought about it seriously this time. I thought about how I would do it and who would cry at my funeral. But most of all, I thought about where all the words I had written would go. They would amount to nothing. Maybe someone would save them for a few months, even a few years. One or two people might read them and feel sad for me. But eventually, they would be thrown out and they would join my vomit in that place where things disappear to. I would go there too. 

I realized that I didn’t want to go into that void of nothingness. If I did, what had happened to me would just go away, and all that suffering would be for nothing. There would be no one to remember how bad it had been, and my death would only prove some childish point that it was worse than people had thought. I was tired of living in this fugue state. I had tasted oblivion and I wanted to spit it out. 

I reached for my old journal, the one that I had so lovingly filled with crooked handwriting. I hadn’t touched it since forgetting, and it was heavier than I remembered. I wondered if perhaps my words had actual weight. The ink that made them must weigh something, and if the journal was so full of it then perhaps I really had made it heavier. 

I opened it and I felt like a little kid again, looking under my bed for monsters.