The Pulsating Moment

Samantha Stone


When Marina got the email asking her to moderate the talk, she didn’t recognize the  author, nor the book, nor the bookstore. Walden Books was located on a side street in the greenest part of Lower Manhattan. It was so picturesque it may as well have been the Hudson Valley trying to pass for the City. The store’s sign was hidden below the building number, which was erected in gold-plated stainless steel, adjacent to the green painted door. In tiny, slanted calligraphy read the store’s name, like it was an afterthought, or if only those with an advanced English degree would be able to  identify the meaning of it. 

***

As she entered the store, she instantly felt like she had traveled back in time to a  universe where words still mattered; the words she had kept inside her head for the better part of a decade now belonged on the outside, and the ones she exchanged carelessly with others wanted to hide inside her subconscious. 

She worried that she forgot to wash her face that morning, because she could feel  tiny pools of oil gathering around the corners of her eyes and lips. The front part of the  store was about as full as you’d expect a bookstore to be on a Wednesday evening in 2025,  but in the back room, there were about sixty folding chairs facing an elevated wooden stage, and nearly all of them were full.  

She walked quickly, unknowingly passing by the check in table. Before she could go much further, a uniformed employee stopped her. “Do you have a ticket?” he asked. 

“Excuse me?” 

“For the talk. Did you RSVP?” 

“Oh… I’m—”

She was cut off by a five-foot one, 23-year-old platinum blonde running over in a frenzy. The woman was wearing baggy jeans and a tank top that showed her midriff. 

“Marina! Marina Wilder,” the woman projected. “I’m Erica.” She jutted her freckled  arm forward. “We spoke on the phone.” 

“Right, yes, hi—” 

“Sorry, would you rather me call you Mrs. Wilder?” 

“Miss, or… Ms. M-S. But no, Marina. Marina’s fine.” 

“She’s with me,” Erica said to the store associate, who seemed mostly taken aback but also a little embarrassed.  

Marina followed Erica through the sea of attendees, most of whom had the book in  their laps. The novel, The Pulsating Moment by Gaia Georgiou, was already a New York Times bestseller and sold out in most stores. Marina had no idea why Gaia agreed to speak at this teeny tiny bookshop, or why either of them did for that matter. 

Erica led Marina to a holding area beside the platformed stage. There wasn’t a green room or anything, but Marina felt that if her previous encounter with the associate was any indication, few of the people seated knew who she was. 

“Thank you for doing this,” Erica beamed. “I’m so fucking obsessed with your reviews. You’re such a cunt it’s fucking delicious.” 

“Uh, thanks… I don’t know if—” 

“No, don’t be modest. You know you’re a fucking cunt.” 

“I guess… it’s just—” 

“What?” 

Marina looked around at the group of people gathered, all so excited to listen for an hour plus about the English language. She thought about how each word in the English language meant something to Gaia, how each word meant something to her readers, how each word meant something to her. 

“It’s just… do you have to use the ‘C’ word?” Marina asked, ignoring how often she’s used that word herself. 

“Oh, shit, I’m sorry! Is that word offensive? Like to your generation? How old are you again?”

“I’m thirty-six.” 

“Fuck, you look, I mean… you just seem so young.” 

“I am young.” 

“No, of course. I just meant… Like young, like, I don’t know, like, my age, young.” 

“I get it. Um, do I just take a seat or…?” 

“Yeah, yes. Of course. Can I get you anything?” 

“No, thanks. I’m fine” 

“Are you sure?”

Marina didn’t know if Erica was testing her or if there was a right or wrong answer to whether she wanted—needed—anything.

“I’m fine,” she reiterated. Her tone was colder, firmer, something she would overanalyze for the remainder of the evening.

“Okay, totally.” Erica ran off somewhere, returning to whatever chaos she left.

***

Marina sat down in the wooden chair which sat perpendicular to another; they  didn’t match but maybe that didn’t matter. Before them was a circular, silvery table that  held two copies of the book, and a small bouquet of white carnations. The carnations were fake, probably to evade the risk of water spilling on the books, though they could have just skipped the flowers altogether, Marina thought. 

The back cover of the book read like a Netflix description: short and mysterious, but engaging enough to whet your interest. 

Thirty-eight-year-old Poppy discovers she’s pregnant on a camping trip with Alex, her  partner of ten years. They’re not married, and don’t plan to be. Never having wanted kids of  her own, she spends the weekend mulling over whether or not, and how, to break the news to him. Their relationship’s fragility is tested in these twenty-four hours, as the two come to  terms with their varied views on civilization, parenthood, and their individual understandings  of gender roles in the modern world. 

Writers Marina loved had blurbed the book. They called it honest, important, and frenetic in the best way. She wondered what she was missing. The prose was confusing but not in a way where she wanted to solve the puzzles it was asking. The characters were unlikable enough not to root for them, but unremarkable enough to not wish them any kind of misfortune. When Marina was sent the book a week ago, she only got about halfway through it before putting it down. She wasn’t the kind of reader who forced herself to finish books she didn’t like, even if she was reading something for work. 

Marina opened to the first page, staring at the opening sentence, which haunted her as much as it did the first time she read it. 

I never want to have children.

In this day and age, a lot of people — at least a lot of people Marina’s age — talked like that. They said having kids sounded too hard, too expensive, that the world is dying anyway so why bother bringing a child into it? 

But seeing those words in writing, knowing the character would eventually have  what she so firmly didn’t want, felt different than hearing it in passing from acquaintances at the gym. Marina wondered if people had become too honest, and if the only way to  experience true escapism anymore was by reading science fiction novels or watching reality television. She wanted to still trust her naivety and believe the stories that made her love reading in the first place.

In high school, she became infatuated with the English language; she loved stories that felt true but a little bit aspirational. Love through the eyes of Jane Austen, misery from the lips of Virginia Woolf, curio through the fingers of Herman Melville. 

In books, we can still dream, Marina hoped. 

***

Gaia Georgiou was at least six feet tall, with dark curly hair and thick chocolate  eyelashes. She looked more like a supermodel than a writer, or at least how Marina came to  imagine writers in her head. She carried a small spiral notepad in her left hand and a  personal copy of the book in her right, so that Marina couldn’t shake either hand even if she wanted to. 

When Gaia sat down, she didn’t look in either direction, deeply focused on whatever was right in front of her. 

“Hi, um, hi…” Marina’s voice broke as if she was trying to give a speech after having laryngitis for a couple days. 

“What?” Her voice wasn’t harsh, but it wasn’t warm either. 

“I’m Marina, the—”  

“Oh. Yes, the critic.” 

“I mean, journalist, essayist, I don’t know. Yeah, I guess critic is fine. A lot of my  pieces are criticism, or forms of criticism. Not just books, all forms of cultural criticism.” 

“Well, cultural criticism refers to an exploration of social or cultural theory. Not just silly reviews. Not that your reviews are silly, just—"

“I don’t know that I would call any book reviews silly, really. I mean… You’re a writer. I would think you’d believe that as much as anyone.” 

“Well, I’m an author.” 

What’s the difference? 

Marina wondered if Gaia could deduce that she had only read half the book, and that’s what she had against her. But more than what it was Gaia didn’t like about Marina, Marina wondered what it was she didn’t like about Gaia. She seemed perfectly nice, at least up until two minutes ago, and she was a woman in the literary arts. She always made it a point to champion them. But something about one another rubbed the other the wrong way, and neither of them could put their finger on what that was. 

***

Book talks rarely began on time, but this one did. Gaia had a hard out at 8:00, and Walden Books always respected their authors’ wishes. 

Marina briefly greeted the crowd and introduced Gaia by way of her work. She mentioned her accolades, her previous bibliography, but she didn’t say anything about The Pulsating Moment. 

“Do you want to tell us what the book is about? You know, in your words.” 

“Sure, well, first, has anyone read it?” A sea of hands shot up; Gaia’s eyes smiled. 

“Thank you, and thank you so much for making time to come chat with us.” She turned her attention to Marina. “You too, Ms. Wilder.” 

Being referred to as Ms. Wilder felt like she was being quoted in an academic journal about a piece she reviewed. Marina was equally flattered and intimidated. “Of course. We’re all thrilled to be here.” 

“It’s a piece about choice, above anything else. It’s my opinion that when choices feel like they’re already made for us, that’s when they’re hardest to make. Does that make  sense?” 

“Absolutely,” Marina confirmed. It made a lot of sense. “And when you say, already  made, I assume you mean choices that are challenged by unavoidable obstacles?” 

“Yes, and sometimes they are undeviating. But sometimes they are more abstract but just as omnipresent. Like time. When a person is pregnant, and she doesn’t want to be, or at  least don’t know if she wants to be, the biggest obstacle isn’t necessarily her body, it’s time. 

I’ve always had these questions about time, and I felt it was the right moment, the pulsating moment you might say, to answer them.” Gaia chortled at her self-reference, and most of the audience humored her. 

Marina didn’t find it as charming, but she thought perhaps she was missing something. “Well, that’s actually a great segue into where I wanted to begin anyway, which is with the inspiration for the novel. In what I know about your work, this seems like a bit of a departure from what you’ve written in the past.” 

“How do you mean?” 

Marina straightened her posture; She slouched when she got nervous. “Well, first of all, the protagonist is a bit older than those of your previous books. And she’s not exactly likable. Is that something you were going for?” 

Gaia pursed her lips. Marina couldn’t tell if she was offended or confused. “Hm.  That’s interesting. I wasn’t not going for that, I guess. I don’t know. Writing is a funny thing, at least writing fiction.” 

“Sure.” 

“Prior to this book, I’d really only written autofiction. I’m pretty narcissistic that way.” 

“I’m sure many of us can relate to that,” Marina offered. The crowd agreed with silent but palpable substantiation.  

“Thanks,” Gaia laughed. “But this one, this story, is something I made up. From start to finish. At least the circumstances, the plot, the setting—” 

“Well, what was true?” 

“I mean it’s all true. You can set a novel at the bottom of a submarine exploring the surface of someone’s ear canal and it’s still true.” 

“Sure.” Marina overused the word ‘sure’ when she got nervous. 

“But I guess to answer the question that I think you’re asking, the characters are true. Or I guess a better word would be real.” 

Marina often pondered the conflict between the coexistence of truth and reality, concepts that you learn to be synonymous in elementary school, distinct but related in high school, and entirely separate from one another in graduate school. 

When Gaia finished speaking, she looked out into the audience for the first time since the start of their discussion. Time stood still for a moment and she managed to focus her eyes on each person’s face, each person that made time out of  their week to come listen to Gaia, and her, talk about not only what was true, but what was real. 

Her meditation broke at the sound of a baby crying. It was the kind of cry that didn’t sound hungry, or tired, or anything that could be immediately resolved. It was the kind of cry that so desperately wanted to be language, to be words that meant something.  

The baby, with whom Marina made the same eye contact she did with the rest of the attendees, was a little girl, no less than a year old but no more than 20 months. She was still young enough that her head was disproportionate to her body, but old enough that she looked like a person, rather than an alien. In fact, she looked like Gaia. Her nose and cheeks were the same shapes and she was watching Marina with the same blank look, in between her wails.

The baby cried more, saying the word ‘mama’ with soft emphasis on the consonants and hard on the vowels, in between her wails. Marina felt bad for her, not because she was  crying, but because she was struggling to communicate. She knew she wanted to contribute  to the conversation, which was something Marina didn’t know how to moderate. 

Gaia’s focus was broken as well, her eyes locked with the child, who was sitting on  the lap ofan elderly woman dressed head to toe in black and white linen. She struggled to hold the child still and was drawing as much attention to herself as the baby. 

The baby started to cough a bit, and Gaia’s unease deepened. The woman holding her grabbed a half-full pink-and-green sippy cup from a portable car seat resting at her feet. The baby drank from it slowly before pushing it down and resuming crying. 

“Can you take her outside?” Gaia asked the woman, who Marina imagined to be the  nanny. The nanny nodded but didn’t say anything. She carried the baby in one arm and the car seat in the other. As the woman stumbled her way through the store, weaving her way  past the rest of the crowd, the baby’s cry got softer but more defined. She continued to repeat the word ‘mama’ until they were out of the store, the crowd responding with mixed reactions. 

Gaia was clutching the book in her hands like it was a fidget toy given to preteens  with behavioral issues. Marina felt sad for her and sad for the baby; she herself struggled  with separation anxiety, and she wasn’t even a mother yet. “Are you good to continue?” she asked.

“Sure,” Gaia said unfazed. Marina felt comfort in their shared use of the word ‘sure.’ “You were talking about the differences between this piece and the others you’ve written. The truth, or reality, I suppose, remains, but the circumstances are made up, which was a departure for you.” 

“Yes, I challenged myself to answer another question, less abstract than the one  about time, and more just a question about life. It’s a question I’ve asked myself my entire life, or at least since I was fourteen years old. That’s when I got my period.” 

“And the question you’re referring to is…” Marina knew what it was, but she thought it was only fair to let Gaia be the one to say it. 

“Whether or not to have a child.” 

“Sure, I think that’s something a lot of us can relate to.” The crowd listened  attentively, though many hadn’t picked the book up to get the answer to that question.

“Can you?” Gaia asked Marina plainly. 

“Can I what?” Marina was stunned. 

“Can you relate to the question?” 

It was rare for Marina to feel like she was the one in the hot seat. For fifteen years, ten of them professionally, she asked other people questions. She never liked to reveal much about who she was, just about how she interpreted things. Maybe that’s why she never became an author. 

“No. Honestly, I can’t.” 

“Do you have kids?” Marina said as more of a statement than a question. “No, no kids. Just… I can’t relate. I’ve always known I’ve wanted children.”

“So then, why no kids?” 

“I mean, no kids yet.” 

“Are you trying?” Gaia was the kind of communicator that not only ignored social normalities but purposefully challenged them. 

“No, I’m not,” Marina said. “I might try someday. But not right now.” 

Gaia looked at Marina differently for the first time since the talk began. Her eyes, which before spoke a language of power now offered compassion, the same compassion they offered to the baby when she was crying. 

“I think that’s really brave to admit,” Gaia said.

“Thanks. And thank you for letting me admit it. I just feel… sorry, do I have your  permission to go off on a minor tangent?” Gaia and the audience agreed.

Marina continued. “We’ve worked hard, some would say really hard, to support the people that don’t want children, or don’t want them now, or can’t have them now, or whatever, but what about the people who do?”

“What about them?” Gaia pursed her lips.

“I assume there are just as many people wishing, dying to have children. Shouldn’t we rally around them?”

“Well, sure. I suppose. I just don’t know that I’ve met anyone like you’re referring to. At least not in New York City.” Gaia smiled. 

“Maybe not. I don’t know. I just think, if I was in the position of your character, I would consider myself the luckiest I’ve ever been in my life.” 

“Well, that’s lovely, but I’m not sure it would make a great novel.”  

Marina sighed a sort of sigh of relief. She finally felt like she understood Gaia. Maybe she should have finished the rest of the book. 

“I think this is a good time to open up questions to the audience.” 

Marina looked to Erica who was ready with a microphone. She looked as dumbfounded as one would expect. Hands went up and the conversation returned to language for a moment. 

***

After the talk concluded, Marina shook Gaia’s hand like she should have done in the beginning. 

“Thank you for this conversation. I found it, I found it really helpful.” 

“Anytime.” Gaia gathered her purse and other belongings. “Well, I guess I’ll see you around.” She nodded at Marina the way an ex would after running into the other on the subway. She started to walk off, narrowly approaching her departure deadline. 

“Also, can I just say…” Marina stopped her before she could completely get away. “You seem like a really good mom. I bet it will be nice to get home to your baby.” 

“What are you talking about?” 

“Your daughter. Who was crying.” 

“That wasn’t my daughter.” 

“What do you mean? Who was it?” 

“I don’t know, just some baby that was crying.” 

“Oh, then, do you, do you even have kids?”

“No, I don’t. I told you, the book’s fiction. I don’t want kids. I have no interest in being a parent. I answered that question for myself while I was writing the book.” Gaia ran off, leaving Marina paralyzed with curiosity. She took a seat again, grabbing  one of the leftover copies of the novel off the table, and opening it to the opposite jacket cover from before. Gaia’s picture was as beautiful as she was in person, and below it was her bio which mentioned her work, husband, two dogs, and zero children. Marina wondered if this was one of those moments where truth and reality challenged each other. Could a person become a mother just because another person believed them to be one, and if that was the case, did Marina have children somewhere in the universe waiting for her to choose them? 

She put on her jacket and headed out of the back of the store, which was virtually empty now. She approached Erica, who handed her an envelope. 

“Thank you. Really. That  was, that was really something.” 

“You’re welcome.” Marina smiled. “And you’re right.” 

“About what?” 

“I am a cunt.” 

***

Marina walked all the way home to her apartment in Williamsburg, Brooklyn that  evening. She hadn’t walked across the Williamsburg Bridge in probably five or six years. She walked the Brooklyn Bridge often enough, when she had family in town, on a second or third date, or when interviewing the quintessential New Yorker for a televised special.  

But she always secretly preferred the Williamsburg Bridge. Maybe it was because of how Betty Smith wrote about it in A Tree Grows in Brooklyn, which was still her favorite  novel. Or maybe because it felt to her more like a functional landmark than a work of art. She always found that people walking this bridge were trying to get somewhere, rather  than trying to experience something. And ironically that encouraged her to slow down and look more closely at what was happening in front of her. 

The sun was setting as Marina crossed the latter part of the bridge’s span. She  noticed parents and their children, walking together, or walking separately. Regardless of  which, this time she knew for a fact they were family.

Halfway across the bridge, Marina heard a child’s voice behind her say ‘mama.’ The pitch was lower and more defined than earlier, but reminiscent. 

She turned. The walkway was empty except for the blur of passing strangers and the river moving black beneath the steel. Then, somewhere above her, the bridge gave a low, pulsing shudder, as if something enormous had shifted in its sleep. Marina placed a hand  over her stomach and felt, beneath her palm, a faint answering flutter. 

Someday.